Assigning to Mark as it looks like something specifically component related. As Mandeep notes, this may not strictly be a regression as the test scripts have been out of sorts. Provided it's a straightforward solution, we should just fix it. If required, we can verify against 1.8 and older 2.0 releases to see how recent it might be.

Problem present in both ICEfaces and ICEfaces2. See screenshot 1.

Fixed. See screenshot 2.

Revision: 22096

Modified : /icefaces/trunk/icefaces/component/src/com/icesoft/faces/component/ext/renderkit/TableRenderer.java

Revision: 22097

Modified : /icefaces2/trunk/icefaces/compat/components/src/main/java/com/icesoft/faces/component/ext/renderkit/TableRenderer.java

The test case is failing on IE browser ( works fine on opera & FF browsers)
Steps to reproduce the problem:
1)Load the application
2)Column 1 & column3 are selected and corresponding column are displayed on the datatable
3)Select checkbox2 for column 2, all three columns in the datatable are displayed
4)Now deselect checkbox1 for column1
Notice that even after deselecting checkbox1 all three columns are still being displayed in the datatable.

This is a completely different problem. Seems there are problems in the partial submit of a checkbox in IE. It looks eerily similar to the numerous checkbox submit problems when working on the test page for sparkle calendar.

Works (with minimalized app.) in Firefox. See video at http://screencast.com/t/NWExMDFmN.

Doesn't work in IE. See video at http://screencast.com/t/NmExZWJmNWE.

Looks like the checkbox issue is a straightforward bug, maybe one of the CS patches for IE6 will resolve it?

I cannot reproduce the issue. I used IE6 and IE8 to test. Maybe other recent fixes solved this issue.

The problem is still manually reproducible on icefaces2 trunk revision# 22313 using IE6, IE& & IE8.

As mentioned in the jira the problem is reproducible only on IE browser.
Steps to reproduce the problem are:

1)Load the application
2)Column 1 & column3 are selected and corresponding column are displayed on the datatable
3)Select checkbox2 for column 2, all three columns in the datatable are displayed
4)Now deselect checkbox1 for column1
Notice that even after deselecting checkbox1 all three columns are still being displayed in the datatable.

FYI, I have also reproduced this issue with the steps above on IE7.

Failing on Icefaces2 trunk revision# 22353
Was passing on Icefaces2 trunk revision# 22344

ICE-3190 is not working as expected.
The Checkbox is not cleared after clicking on the clean button, all other components on the page are cleared.
Test application is available at " \repo\qa\trunk\Regression-Icefaces2\Nightly\ICE-3190".

ICE-2283 test application has the delta submit turned by default. This caused the apparent regression. Changed web.xml to disable delta submit.

ICE-3190 is not passing yet, and does not have deltaSubmit=true specified. (See Mandeep's comment above).

Previously the decode() method assumed that the checkbox is selected only when the corresponding parameter had a value of 'on', 'true' or 'yes'. Since the encoding didn't control the 'value' attribute of the input element the renderer was relying only on the default behavior of the browser to set the value to 'on'. Unfortunately not all the browsers have the same default behavior, notably Safari which will default the value to empty string after an update.

The fix changes decode() method to reliably detect when checkbox is selected by simply verifying if the corresponding parameter name is present among the request parameters. This is enough to indicate that the checkbox is selected, the value of the corresponding parameter is not significant.

ICE-3190 passed during nightly regression test on Icefaces2 trunk revision# 22397