To Mark Collette: In our project, a user click on calendar schedule (MyFaces), then the calendar will pop up a popup panel with the clicked time. If the user click cancel button and click on another time, then the popup will get another the clicked time. However, if I set immediate=true, the popup always keep the first clicked time. Only after I set the immediate=false, then use can always get his clicked time on each click. But when setting immediate=false, the popup will validate each required field when use click Cancel, that is very bad. Thanks.

Sheng Gu: Ok, so do you have an ice:selectInputDate with renderAsPopup="true", or are you making your own popup panel display? Is the cancel button an actual commandButton, or the X button on the calendar popup? You're setting immediate="true" on this cancel commandButton, or on the selectInputDate?

Hi Mark, we did not use ice:selectInputDate with renderAsPopup="true" as a popup in our schedule (seven week day columns) page. We have our own popup panel display which shows the clicked time (date and time) as schedule start time, schedule title and schedule interval. There are two ice:commandButton buttons on the popup panel: one is submit button, the other is cancel button. If I set cancel button immediate="true", the schedule start time will always keep the first clicked time, even click cancel then click another time. Only I set cancel button immediate=false, then the schedule time can get lastest clicked time. Thank you.

For panelPopup users more suitable will be code below.
Use this when inputs and Cancel button is on the same panelGrid.

In my case I saw that original recurse function not work correct on panelPopup
and gives this log :

1. getForm uicomponent com.icesoft.faces.component.ext.HtmlCommandButton@1866417
2. getForm uicomponent com.icesoft.faces.component.UIXhtmlComponent@1386211:tag=[div]
3. getForm uicomponent com.icesoft.faces.component.ext.HtmlPanelGrid@ac2d3c
4. getForm uicomponent com.icesoft.faces.component.panelpopup.PanelPopup@1cdc190
5. getForm uicomponent com.icesoft.faces.component.ext.HtmlForm@15ede11
6. clearSubittedFormValuesRecurse class com.icesoft.faces.component.ext.HtmlForm
7. clearSubittedFormValuesRecurse class com.icesoft.faces.component.panelpopup.PanelPopup

That means then ..PanelPopup don't get their childrens.
So I change UIForm to UIPanel and getting childrens and clearing state work correct

/**

• @see clearSubmittedFormValues
• @param uiComponent
  */
  private static void clearSubittedFormValuesRecurse(UIComponent uiComponent)
  {
  System.out.println("clearSubittedFormValuesRecurse "+uiComponent);
  if (uiComponent instanceof UIInput) { UIInput uiInput = (UIInput) uiComponent; uiInput.setSubmittedValue(null); System.out.println("clearSubittedFormValuesRecurse "+uiInput.getId()); }

  List<?> childList = uiComponent.getChildren();
  if (childList != null)

  Unknown macro: { Iterator<?> iterator = childList.iterator(); while (iterator.hasNext()) { clearSubittedFormValuesRecurse((UIComponent) iterator.next()); } }

  }

/**

• Util for clearSubmittedFormValues
• @see clearSubmittedFormValues
• @param uiComponent
• @return
  */
  public static /UIForm/UIPanel getForm(UIComponent uiComponent)
  {
  while (uiComponent != null)
  Unknown macro: { System.out.println("getForm uicomponent"+ uiComponent); if (uiComponent instanceof UIPanel /*UIForm*/) { break; } uiComponent = uiComponent.getParent(); }

  return (/(UIForm)/ (UIPanel) uiComponent);
  }

Duplicate of ICE-1741.