The recent checkin allows the standard component-showcase to work on glassfish-v2-b41 with the server-provided jsf implementation (the fix involves special-cases for how parameters are passed to JSP tags, so it may have indirect dependencies on Sun code).

However, it currently exhibits the following problems:

• selectInputDate component displays but is not interactive
• page is blank on first render

auctionMonitor returns a blank page even on repeated reloads.

component-showcase and auctionMonitor are now working in JSP mode with JSF 1.2.

D2DViewHandler is now checking specifically for JSF 1.2 and, if detected, renders the page at the end of parsing. In JSF 1.1, the ViewTag invokes this rendering, but this does not appear to occur with JSF 1.2.

The integration should be improved so that a single icefaces.jar can handle both the JSF 1.2 case and the JSF 1.1 case.

This likely requires building the stock icefaces.jar with JDK 1.5 (because the JSF 1.2 classes will be JDK 1.5 versioned).

A new .jar file, lib/jsf-api-1.2.jar (JSF 1.2 interfaces) has been added, so
if you are building against everything in icefaces/lib
you are bound to have problems (JSP classes not found).

A full icefaces.jar is now intended to be built on JDK 1.5
with 1.4 targets for the bulk of the classes and 1.5 targets
for only the tomcat 6 and JSF 1.2 portions. (A .jar built in
this way would be portable to JSF 1.2 and 1.2 on both
JDK 1.4 and 1.5.)

auctionMonitor and component-showcase in JSP mode should now
work with JSF 1.2 on glassfish, although the builds
for these samples are not targeted for this configuration
(they need .jar files removed: el-api.jar, jstl.jar,
xercesImpl.jar, xml-apis.jar, jsf-api.jar, and jsf-impl.jar).

Note that this does not address the JSF 1.2/1.2 "compatibility mode"
scenario raised in ICE-1474; ICEfaces applications still require
JSF 1.1 faces-config.xml.

Probably should have re-opened this before, but the recent checkins address the need for more specific types expected by the standard JSF components. (ICEfaces components are using pre JSP 2.1 tags, hence are content with Object or String.)
This likely does not cover all the required cases, so additional testing is necessary.

Please test the samples and tutorials on Tomcat 6 and GlassFish.

Re-opening to account for testing results.

Tested under Glassfish V2-b41 and Tomcat 6.0
Auction Monitor - Works for both
Address Demo - Works for both
Component Showcase - Works for both but exhibits some styling issues, changing theme to royale puts a blue overlay on top of everything, big space between navigation tree and component content area, top header image is broken up.
basicInputText - Works for both
dragdrop1 - Works for both
dragdrop2 - Page loads ok but cannot drag the grey area, throws no errors, same for both
effects1 - Works for both
effects2 - Same as dragdrop2, page shows, components aren't functional
tiles - Shows everything except the body of the timezone part, throws error
timezone1 to 7 - Works for both

Theoretically we should implement type safety for JSP 2.1 using javax.servlet.jsp.tagext.TagInfo, but these info classes are not available because they are not created by the ICEfaces TLD parser.

dragdrop2 and effectsd problems appear to be caused by <jsp:forward page="./dragdrop.iface" /> in index.jsp (replace with dragdrop.iface). Will create a separate JIRA for this.

Testing indicates that bug is resolved. Created ICE-1751 for the non-interactive tutorials (bug unrelated to JSF 1.2 support).